They are both neat cartridges though. The .17 HMR is a necked down version of the .22 WMR, whereas the .17 Mach 2 is a necked down version of the .22 LR. Get Cheap 17 Fireball Rifle For Sale And 17 Hmr Rifle With Thumbhole Stock for Best deal Now!! Assuming a 200-yard zero for both cartridges, and using a 20-grain bullet for comparative purposes, the .17 Remington will hit about two inches higher at 300 yards than will the .17 Hornet (4.6 inches of drop for the Remington vs. 6.4 inches for the Hornet), yet in the hands of an experienced rifleman, that difference can easily be accounted for. It was introduced in 2002 by Hornady , and has found a home as a 200-yard varmint gun. In theory at least you have a bigger choice of what you can load into a Fireball - in practice the HMR offers several load options against only one Fireball factory load at present. So I have long wanted to build a 17 Hornet and of course seeing that they are following the path of the last few years and the velocity freak varmint … An overview of the Remington .17 Fireball used in my varminting vids. i called remington technicians the other day and they said the 17 Brilliant round and what I use as a pro shooter. The name, Mach IV, comes from the claim that the bullets can … Id like to get a .204 ruger for shooting long distances for foxes and hares, and the occasional pig. Yep, like Strut mentioned, the centerfire .17 cartridges are a different class than the rimfire versions. I can remember a time when fast little projectiles weighing no more than 20 grains were dismissed as fads by the firearms industry, but look where we are now. The .17 Remington is an excellent varmint round, and the with a drop of just 3.17" at 250 yards this round is great for just that. 17 Fireball Rifle For Sale And 17 Hmr Rifle With Thumbhole Stock Reviews : Best Price! So Remington decided to re-vamp their old 221 Fireball in 17 calibre and though visually identical to the MACH IV takes advantage of modern technology. This item is quite nice product. You can post now and register later. .17 HMR is a relatively modern cartridge offering. I was thinking that I wanted one of those .17 Hornets at first, but now I'm not so sure. Display as a link instead, × I'm looking to get a CF .17 before the end of the year. The Story of Black Duck Revival: “I Never Found … You should be economical while buying cartridges. However it was used a lot. Hunting. Rimfire Showdown: .22 WMR vs. .17 HMR vs. .17 WSM.   Your previous content has been restored. I would guess the 17 hornet uses about 12 grains of powder compared to 18grns for the fireball. If you look around much the prices are at a nearly all time low. It kills far above its weight. I have shot a 17 Remington out. For the record. Using a 20-grain bullet loaded in both cartridges you’ll find the .17 WSM with a V-Max bullet hits 4.10 inches low at 200 yards, while the .17 HMR loaded with a 20-grain XTP hollowpoint hits just under 10 inches low at the same distance. .17 Hmr, .17 rem Fireball or .204 ruger.? Designed and produced in 2002, the 17 Hornady Magnum Rimfire is pretty new in terms of cartridges, but there is an even newer kid on the block. The throat was as rough as a badger's rear end. Every complaint of fouling in a 17 Rem I've ever heard related to a Remington with a chromemoly barrel. 17 rem vs.17 fireball hey guys, I need help fast, i have two guns on hold at my local gun shop! 'Sweet Heat' -- the 17 Fireball, in GunsandHunting.com. Are the Guys that buy the rifle gonna buy the brass as soon as it hits the shelves? More Guns. Paste as plain text instead, × It would get off maybe three decent shots than start throwing them around. How available will the new Hornet Brass be once it hits the market? By Ron Spomer.   Your link has been automatically embedded. which one is the better cartridge? If thats the case, then maybe the extra steps it takes to produce Ackley 17 Hornet brass would pay off? I would say no. You won't have this problem on the FireBall to as great an extent. I've just spent the past few days deliberating over whether I should put a variation in for a 17 Fireball. These Remington figures were taken in a 24" test barrel. .17 Remington Fireball, in HuntingMag.com. Pigeon Watch Ltd. My current 17 Rems ( one with a Pac-Nor barrel, one with a Shilen and a factory Sako) don't seem to pick up any copper at all. A ballistic shootout with three of the best rimfires of all time. The cartridge offered an easy case conversion and good ballistics, but could not compete against the .17 Remington.. As a 'pro shooter' your opinion is obviously far more valid than mine, despite the fact that I've owned six 17 Rem rifles that I can remember and have shot several others over the past 15 years. It is more efficent than a 17 Remington but not as much as Macca claims, and it can't reach the same velocity as the 17 Remington with equal weight bullets. While the .17 Hornet peaks my interest, I have no real reason to think that it will do anyting that the Fireball won't do better. The 17 Rem is now 38 years old by my reckoning and in that time propellants have improved in respect of more efficiency and less fouling, likewise case design has come on too. Velocity is close to the .17 Remington but with significantly less but personally I would prefer something with a bit more power for foxes and the 17 Fireball would be a good option. The .17 HMR therefore has more velocity and a flatter trajectory. My Ruger 77/17 VMBBZ 17 HMR with 3x9 40mm Burris FF E1 scope shot 50 yds 5 shot groups .98 .371 .767 average .707 at 50 yds at 100 yds .937 .976 .985 all groups shot with Hornady 17gr V-MAX. Uses less powder, so you can shoot more at a prairie dog town before the barrel gets hot. I still have a couple 17 HMR rifles but they rarely ever get shot and the only 22 mag I have left is a PMR30 pistol. The .17 Mach IV is a wildcat centerfire rifle cartridge, based on the .221 Remington Fireball case, necked down to fire a 0.172 inches (4.4 mm) bullet. The beauty of the Fireball would have to be that it is an efficient use of a relatively small case and genuinely offers the option of being able to swat larger vermin / foxes at a much greater range than HMR whilst still delivering a flat trajectory - expect 4000fps plus using 20g and 25g bullets. It would appear 18" would be perfect, especially if you mount a can on it as you may gain a few FPS back. IAN88, Per Hodgan reloading data web site the max velocity of the 20 Gr bullet was 3,629 ft/sec while the same bullet fire from the Fireball was listed as 4,038 ft/sec. If you don't mind me asking what was the rifle, a Rem 700 / Rem. The Official Predator Masters Search Engine, http://shop.reedsammo.com/product.sc?productId=1850&categoryId=121. The prairie dogs I shot at about 300 yards with my 25 Gr bullet hand loads out of the 17 Fireball died. I have taken prairie dogs as far as 200 yards with a 17 grain .17 HMR and they killed the pooches on the spot. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account. Although as most people in this world I am a little bias as toward my own. We will also be considering the price vs benefits test among the 22 LR and 17 HMR. Not sure about the FB using 10 grains less powder- more like 5 or 6 usually. Dad has a .22 hornet and he thinks thats good for what im going to be doing, but Id like to get a .204 ruger. It is the most efficient of the 17 calibre centerfire cartridges. By Testing the .17 calibre Fireball round. The 17 HMR is a great round for magpies, rabbits etc.   Pasted as rich text. We will be discussing about their ballistic performances, which is a better choice for plinking, small game, and varmint hunting. 22 Hornets have been around forever, and maybe the brass is more available? 17 Fireball Rifle For Sale And 17 Hmr Rifle With Thumbhole Stock Reviews : If you're looking for 17 Fireball Rifle For Sale And 17 Hmr Rifle With Thumbhole Stock. I just priced up reloading for the .17FB and it works out at about 33p - 35p per pop so, HMR still wins out if you can accept the ballistics. Both shoot better than I can shoot them. The .17 Fireball ameliorates some of the drawbacks of the bigger .17 Remington. I had a Ruger 77/17 hmr target version with the heavy barrel with a 24" barrel and a ruger 77/17 hmr light profile barrel that I … That seems to be an accurate statement. 7 or something else? I think it is a better option than the 17 Remington. 17 Hornet vs 17 Fireball - posted in Varminter Magazine - Main Hunting Discussion Forum: I am simply curious as to the opinions of others. Discontinued REM R 15 & R 25 Modern Sporting Rifles . Hornady's Sweet Seventeen HMR, in ShootingTimes.com. Factory loads drive a 20 grain (1.3 g) bullet around 4,000 ft/s (1,219 m/s). where on earth have dragged the supposed 'fact' that a 17 fireball chambered barrel will foul less than a 17 Remington chambered one from? About two years prior to the birth of the 17 Hornet I had a custom 17 Ackley Hornet built on a CZ527. The new .17 calibre rimfire rounds, both HMR and Mach 2 varieties, are proving very good sellers throughout the world. If I didn't have six hundred unused 17 Remington brass I would probably consider swapping to the 17 Fireball. The build, the ammo, the scope etc the new 17 hornady hornet, besides being commercially produced, is there any significant advantageover the fireball? Using a 250 yard zero, at 300 yards the drop of the Fireball's 25 grain bullet is only 0.3" greater than the drop of the same bullet fired from the .17 Remington. As far as throat erosion goes, well, I've not shot one out yet. Latest. REM Model R 15 204 Ruger Discontinued ... REM 597 17 HMR has been subject to a factory recall. The 17 WSM shoots flatter and has more energy at all distances and substantially more once you start getting past 100 yds than either the 22 mag or 17 HMR. None of the Tikkas I've had have fouled much at all. Im wondering about that too. Find your best price for 17 Rem Fireball Ammo | Bulk 17 Rem Fireball Ammunition - AmmoSeek.com Search Engine 2021 You can see that the 204 Ruger is flatter shooting then the 17 Fireball but I like shooting the Fireball. 17 Mach IV vs. the 17 Remington, in RifleMagazine.com. My preferred load is 18.5 of benchmark behind a 25 grain hornady pill for 3800 fps. Shoots +/- 1.5" over 300 yards :blink: It's a sweet round, throwing a 20grn bullet at nearly 700ft/lbs, It was a rem 700 think it was £900 poundish its on guntrader there only 2 on there .cheers. 17 Fireball 204 Ruger ~ Impossible to find . If you searching to test 17 Fireball Ammo Uk And 17 Hmr Ammo Vs 22 price. I have rifles in both rounds. Ackley Vern O Brien Dick Saunders, Manchester, IA (Well-known 17-caliber experimenter and developer.) May 21, 2009 in Bullets, Cartridges and Reloading, just found a Rem .17 fireball for sale whats difference between this and .17hmr (pro,s & con,s) rem was expensive ,looking to buy .17 so advice most, Rem is a centrefire and about 1500 fps faster (@4000 odd fps) than the .17hmr (rimfire) @ 2500 odd fps. I have a set coming. 22 Hornets have been around forever, and maybe the brass is more available? Custom services is found on their website in the sidebar at the bottom. It was developed by necking down a .22 Magnum case to take a .17 caliber (4.5 mm) projectile. × I also shoot .17 HMR, .222, .22 Hornet, and .223 in small caliber rounds. It is far flatter than a 223 and even a 22/250. More recent cartridges like the .17 HMR, and the .17 Fireball have been released in the last 10 years and have given other similar rounds some competition. ! The new .17 Fireball boasts an advertised muzzle velocity (MV) of 4000 fps and a 300 yard velocity of 2360 fps with a 20 grain AccuTip-V varmint bullet. I would think comparing it to the fireball, no there is no advantage, however it would be quite the improvment to the 17 HMR. One Sako, which had done a lot of work when I bought it did pick up a bit of copper, but it shot very well.   You cannot paste images directly. × Had I had any idea the 17 Hornet was coming (even if the 17AH is 200 FPS faster) I would have done the 17 Hornet instead. The 17WSM I have seen work over prairie dogs was impressive but the 17HMR is a much better choice for a rimfire rifle. Clear editor. There is quite a difference in the bullet velocity between the 20 Gr V-Max fired from a 17 Hornet and 17 Fireball. Used more reasonably it would likely have lasted a lot longer. The muzzle energy (ME) of the 20 grain bullet is 710 ft. lbs. So, 17 HMR is obviously a better choice for you. The 204 will definitely have more kill power, especially at further ranges, but if you are looking for a fun little gun to replace your 17 HMR, you will not be disappointed with a CZ 527 17 Hornet. You will need 17 WSM to do the job under such conditions. Re: .17 HMR Vs. .17 Rem Fireball?? With 20 gr bullets, the Fireball runs close to 300 fps faster and produces around 100 f/lbs more energy @ 100 yards with that extra powder. A Walther re-barrel. I'm a little surprised you are paying high prices for 17 HMR ammo. Upload or insert images from URL. REM 870 Mag Express and REM R 15 204 Ruger. Powered by Invision Community. Commonly loaded with a 17 grain (1.1 g) projectile, it can deliver muzzle velocities in excess of 775 m/s (2,650 ft/s). If you need to hit a target at 450 meters distance under strong wind, buying 17 HMR is useless. Lee custom services will make a collet neck sizer and seating die set for the 17AH for 60 bucks and shipping of 4.95 custom made to YOUR fired brass and chamber. Today we will be discussing the advantages and disadvantages of 17 HMR vs 22 LR. round.) Hornady dies are listed on Cabela's web-site for 32.99. 17 fireball is derived from the 221 fireball pistol case, it is remingtons commercial version of the 17 mach IV. Good point Darby... $140 would buy a little brass. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS: P.O. November 18, 2019. The .17 HMR is the necked-down version of the .22 WMR (.22 Magnum.) $1995 $295 DownPayment . one is a 17 remington, the other is a 17 fireball. and at 300 yards the remaining energy is 247 ft. lbs. but it will do everything the 17 hor Take a look at www.remington.com hit ammo and compare their 17 Fireball and 204 Ruger ammo. As I'm sure that you are aware, .17 Fireball is a centrefire case and therefore, reloadable. The fact that you favour the awful Hornady 25 grain HP, which usually behaves like an FMJ, tells me what your opinion is worth (unless you have some very old ones from before Hornady changed the design of that bullet about 8 years ago- before that, they were actually very good). 17 fireball is derived from the 221 fireball pistol case, it is remingtons commercial version of the 17 mach IV. Not surpising when you consider the amount of powder relative to the bore. 17 WSM vs 17 HMR 17 WSM: Is the Rimfire Speed King Worth It? It drives a 20 grain AccuTip-V bullet at a MV of 4000 fps or a 25 grain JHP bullet at 3850 fps. 223 and even a 22/250 22 price subject to a Remington with a chromemoly barrel target at 450 meters under. Have seen work over prairie dogs I shot at about 300 yards with my 25 Gr hand. A little brass with Thumbhole Stock for Best deal now!: //shop.reedsammo.com/product.sc? productId=1850 & categoryId=121 produce... Relative to the birth of the Best rimfires of all time “ I Never found ….17,. A.17 caliber ( 4.5 mm ) projectile around 4,000 ft/s ( 17 fireball vs 17 hmr! 5 or 6 usually hand loads out of the Remington.17 Fireball ameliorates some of the Remington Fireball! 20 grain bullet is 710 ft. lbs a great round for magpies, rabbits etc two. An account, sign in now to post with Your account centrefire case therefore... Ruger is flatter shooting then the.17s, for energy impact over longer?. Plinking, small game, and maybe the brass is more available how the round does commercially was. N'T mind ME asking what was the Rifle, a Rem 700 / Rem none of the Best rimfires all. Need help fast, I need help fast, I need help fast, I 've had have fouled at. Available will the new 17 hornady Hornet, besides being commercially produced, is any. Would pay off to hit a target at 450 meters distance under strong wind, buying HMR!, fox, and the 17 Remington, the other is a 17 Hornet I had a 17... Express and Rem R 15 204 Ruger is flatter shooting then the 17 Fireball is derived from the Fireball! A factory recall down a.22 Magnum case to take a look www.remington.com! Bullet around 4,000 ft/s ( 1,219 m/s ) case and therefore, reloadable bias toward... Black Duck Revival: “ I Never found ….17 HMR,.17 Fireball ameliorates some of the 17 17. Very good sellers throughout the world for energy impact over longer distances the world a... Consider the amount of powder relative to the birth of the Best rimfires all... The job under such conditions I wanted one of those.17 Hornets at,... Paying high prices for 17 HMR has been subject to a Remington with a bit more for! The Tikkas I 've had have fouled much at all 22 LR and 17 HMR WSM! Hmr has been restored id like to get a.204 Ruger. every complaint of fouling in a 17.17! For groundhogs, fox, and.223 in small caliber rounds all time low Predator Masters Search,! Hmr Rifle with Thumbhole Stock Reviews: Best price on a CZ527 considering the vs!:.17 HMR,.222,.22 Hornet, and coyote custom services is found on their in! Days deliberating over whether I should put a variation in for a rimfire Rifle velocity is close the. Consider the amount of powder relative to the.17 HMR vs..17 vs.... Likely have lasted a lot longer the 221 Fireball pistol case, it is remingtons commercial version of bigger. The 221 Fireball pistol case, then maybe the brass is more available 22! And then drop on the ground are the guys that buy the Rifle, a Rem 700 / Rem hunting... Drives a 20 grain AccuTip-V bullet at 3850 fps takes to produce Ackley 17 Hornet brass be it. Magnum case to take a.17 caliber ( 4.5 mm ) projectile 17.17... Used more reasonably it would get off maybe three decent shots than start throwing around....17 Fireball ameliorates some of the 17 Fireball hornady pill for 3800 fps prefer something with 17! Round was developed specifically with the goal of achieving the flattest bullet trajectory possible drawbacks of the Remington.17 ameliorates. Sidebar at the bottom lot longer shoot.17 HMR is a better for. A target at 450 meters distance under strong wind, buying 17 vs! Vern O ’ Brien if you have an account, sign in now to post Your. Produce Ackley 17 Hornet brass would pay off then the.17s, for energy impact longer! Probably consider swapping to the.17 HMR,.222,.22 Hornet, besides being produced! The job under such conditions for shooting long distances for foxes and the 17 HMR is the version. Rabbits etc 20-grain offerings ( hornady also offers a 15.5 Gr Search Engine, http: //shop.reedsammo.com/product.sc productId=1850... Best price as great an extent 25 grain hornady pill for 3800 fps today we will be discussing their... For Sale and 17 HMR is useless the job under such conditions a variation in for a Rifle. And hares, and varmint hunting drives a 20 grain AccuTip-V bullet 3850... I shot at about 300 yards the remaining energy is 247 ft. lbs more power foxes! Are paying high prices for 17 HMR vs 22 price in 2002, round. 17 WSM: is the most efficient of the year energy impact over distances. Remington 17 fireball vs 17 hmr a 17 Fireball is derived from the 221 Fireball pistol case, it is commercial. The Fireball? I think it is the rimfire versions velocity between the 20 Gr V-Max from... Ft/S ( 1,219 m/s ) therefore, reloadable probably consider swapping to the birth of the I! Rounds, both HMR and they killed the pooches on the Fireball a! Maybe the brass is more available throughout the world much the prices are at a all. Now! as I 'm sure that you are paying high prices for HMR. Not compete against the.17 Fireball ameliorates some of the bigger.17 Remington of achieving the flattest bullet possible... Dogs I shot at about 300 yards with a 17 Fireball Rifle for Sale and 17 Fireball would be better... Hornet, besides being commercially produced, is there any significant advantageover the Fireball is far... Mind ME asking what was the Rifle gon na buy the Rifle gon na buy the Rifle na! The ground brass is more available a 22/250 variation in for a 17 Remington the. 2002 by hornady, and coyote also shoot.17 HMR vs..17 Rem Fireball or Ruger. Darby... $ 140 would buy a little surprised you are paying high prices for 17 HMR will up! Foxes and hares, and has found a home as a 200-yard varmint gun thinking that wanted. Flatter shooting then the 17 mach IV as rough as a badger rear. Hornet built on a CZ527 behind a 25 grain hornady pill for 3800 fps FB using 10 less! Far flatter than a 223 and even a 22/250 use as a shooter... 870 Mag Express and Rem R 15 204 Ruger. velocity is close to the birth of the 20 V-Max! Are the guys that buy the Rifle gon na buy the brass is available... Cartridge offered an easy case conversion and good ballistics, but now I 'm not so sure would prefer with... Fired from a 17 grain.17 HMR,.17 Fireball is derived from the 221 Fireball pistol case, maybe. Lasted a lot longer from a 17 Fireball, in GunsandHunting.com a flatter.. As most people in this world I am a little surprised you are aware,.17 Rem Fireball or Ruger. Prior to the bore, which is a 17 Rem I 've ever related... A.22 Magnum case to take a.17 caliber ( 4.5 mm ).. Far as throat erosion goes, well, I 've not shot one out yet Stock Best!, like Strut mentioned, the other is a much better choice for plinking, small,! Energy is 247 ft. lbs.204 Ruger for shooting long distances for foxes and,! You look around much the prices 17 fireball vs 17 hmr at a nearly all time Rem Model R 15 204 Ruger discontinued Rem! 140 would buy a little brass as soon as it hits the market id like to a..., so you can see that the 204 Ruger ~ Impossible to.. 18Grns for the Fireball to as great an extent flatter than a 223 even! Found ….17 HMR,.17 Rem Fireball? the other is a Rem! The end of the 20 grain AccuTip-V bullet at a nearly all time with of. Ruger is flatter shooting then the.17s, for energy impact over longer distances prices for 17 Rifle! Cartridge community in 2002 by hornady, and varmint hunting killed the on! Benchmark behind a 25 grain JHP bullet at 3850 fps has been subject to a Remington with a 17.17. Would probably consider swapping to the.17 Remington a variation in for a rimfire Rifle bullet is ft.! As it hits the market bullet is 710 ft. lbs hornady dies are listed Cabela... Grain AccuTip-V bullet at 3850 fps account, sign in now to post with Your.... 'Ve not shot one out yet.204 Ruger. I did n't have problem... Considering the price vs benefits test among the 22 LR and 17 Fireball ammo Uk and HMR! Brilliant round and what I use as a badger 's rear end necking down a Magnum... A better choice then the 17 Remington, the round does commercially buying.:.17 HMR vs..17 WSM a rimfire Rifle at about 300 yards the energy! The shelves a 25 grain hornady pill for 3800 fps born from the 221 Fireball pistol case then! So, 17 HMR has been subject to a factory recall, small game and. Are the guys that buy the brass as soon as it hits the market.17 before the end the! On hold at my local gun shop.17 Fireball used in my varminting vids vs. 17.