This and the fact that she isn't Jewish are why she believes she survived. It was only later that I learned they were burning bodies because they couldn't keep up with the crematoriums alone.". That is why, since its creation in 2009, the foundation that raises money to maintain the site of Auschwitz-Birkenau has had a guiding philosophy: “To preserve authenticity.” However, the song was first published in 1956. Prior to focusing on a more detailed discussion of some exhibitions that need preservation due to their frailty and emotional loading, it seems reasonable to discuss the arguments in favor of preserving Auschwitz in general. The first Auschwitz trial was held according to the laws against war criminals and crimes against humanity, the legal code that was established in the Nuremberg Trials. The name Auschwitz stands alone as a symbol of the horrors wrought by Adolf Hitler's regime in Nazi Germany. Unlike the memorials at other camp sites, which might contain a statue or several commemorative plaques, Auschwitz is preserved the way it was in 1945 right down to the original barracks, guard towers and barbed wire fencing (no longer electrified.) "Our hair was shaved and they tattooed numbers on our arms.". People should look at this place and think about our moral responsibility. Matthew Evans, Sutton. So should be the efforts to ensure that it is well kept in perpetuity. As the world has witnessed, Holocaust denial efforts can gain acceptance and credibility with shocking ease. Auschwitz was a Nazi controlled concentration, extermination and labor camp located in Poland. On the contrary, 70 years after the burning ovens ceased their deadly work at Birkenau, where at least 960,000 Jews were murdered, the Auschwitz-Birkenau Foundation announced it has raised 109 million of the 120-million Euros it needs to ensure the site is preserved in perpetuity. After the German officers saw the documents, they exempted Fabian from service. The Soviet army liberated Auschwitz 75 years ago, on Jan. 27, 1945. Over 1.1 million people were murdered at Auschwitz, including nearly a million Jews. "When we got off the train, we were taken to a large hall, where we stripped down completely," she remembers. Auschwitz had been liberated, but the war still plodded on, shaping the massive camp complex. Many among the first group were sent to gas chambers before they were listed in the camp's books, which is why the total number of victims and their identity remains unknown. Written and recorded accounts by survivors do this important work, as does an extensive film and photographic record from the era. "I was always hiding the number on my arm, so that I wouldn't have to talk about it. The second trial was held within the framework of German criminal law, making it more difficult to convict some of the accused. Another Auschwitz survivor, Janina Iwanska, now 89 and living in Warsaw, was deported to the camp at the height of the killing in 1944. Dabrowska remembers the horror of noticing a friend's body among a pile of bodies of the executed. She rolls up her sleeve to show hers: a small, faded black "44165" etched into her forearm. Auschwitz, also known as Auschwitz-Birkenau, opened in 1940 and was the largest of the Nazi concentration and death camps. On the day of liberation 75 years ago, only 7,000 were saved. As the generation of Holocaust survivors dwindles in number, humanity must rely on other means to combat these hateful distortions of history. And they identify with being Jewish. There she was, just lying there. Visits by some 1.4 million tourists annually — triple the number who came just 10 years ago — have taken their toll. Rob Schmitz/NPR She was sent to Auschwitz after she was separated from her parents at the age of 14 during the Warsaw Uprising in 1944 when the Nazis laid siege to the city. When German soldiers first imprisoned Dabrowska, they executed her accomplices, including her brother. This year, the card with a message wishing a peaceful holiday season included a photograph of Chinese soldiers marching past Uighur children in Xinjiang, where China's government has sent an estimated 1 million ethnic Muslims to internment camps. Why Auschwitz Plays Such a Central Role in Holocaust Remembrance. hide caption. I feel that the camp should be preserved by the international community. Pawel Sawicki, a guide at the museum, has seen thousands of tourists come from all over the world. She instinctively turned around and never tried it again. The camp was designated by Nazi leader Heinrich Himmler as the place of the "final solution of the Jewish question in Europe.". Berlin Rabbi Daniel Fabian's grandmother survived Auschwitz but never talked about her time there. It is also probable that another factor was the usefulness of the Museum in the Cold War propaganda struggle. Each December, Piotr M.A. On the contrary, 70 years after the burning ovens ceased their deadly work at Birkenau, where at least 960,000 Jews were murdered, the Auschwitz-Birkenau Foundation announced it has raised 109 million of the 120-million Euros it needs to ensure the site is preserved in perpetuity. Perhapse it should be considered as a world heritage site? What left the deepest impression on me was watching those marches to the chambers where so many were murdered. More than 100 thousand objects and archival items, 150 preserved buildings, and approximately 300 ruins, including the remains of four gas chambers and crematoria in Birkenau, over 13 km of fence with 3.6 thousand concrete posts and many other elements are under the care of highly-qualified conservators having one of the most modern specialist laboratories in the world at their disposal. She was sent to Auschwitz after she was caught by the Nazis helping the Allied forces in German-occupied Poland during World War II. If someone couldn't take it anymore, they jumped over the ditch and threw themselves onto the electric fence and their lives were over.". It was only when he was required to sign up for German military service that he says he began to realize what his grandmother had been through. They [still] are able to do it. hide caption. As the world marks the 75th anniversary of the liberation of Auschwitz, Edith Friedman Grosman, who was 17 when she arrived at the Nazi concentration … More than 2 million people visit the Auschwitz museum each year. She was an inmate at a prison in Nazi-occupied Poland — incarcerated for helping Allied forces — and one day in 1943, while walking the grounds, a new arrival warned her about it. But in the almost half century that Poland lived under communism, it lacked the means to do the job. The Holocaust was a global event, and should therfore the camps should be preserved for future generations by the international community. Opened in 1940, the camp was liberated in 1945 by Soviet troops. In an eight-week period between May and July, guards killed 330,000 people. Some 1.3 million people were deported to the camp, and 1.1 million died there. Snow-covered personal effects of those deported to the Auschwitz concentration camp in … Electric barbed wire fence and concrete pillars of Auschwitz concentration camp have been preserved as part of the Auschwitz-Birkenau State Museum. "This is the largest preservation project in the history of the museum at Auschwitz-Birkenau. Why preserve and restore? Cywinski, the Polish director of the Auschwitz museum, sends a holiday card with a similar reminder. Auschwitz is the most notorious of the hundreds of concentration camps that the German Nazis dotted across Europe. That snow belonged to her. Located in southern Poland, Furthermore, preservation initiatives become even more complicated due to various existing attitudes towards the site, with some people believing that it should come to natural destruction. The death camp is a monument that must be preserved so that its madness and atrocities are never repeated. ", Auschwitz survivor Alina Dabrowska, 96, shows her Auschwitz prisoner number tattoo at her home in Warsaw. The campaign, intended to create a "perpetual fund" to care for Auschwitz, has been given a large boost toward its goal of $165 million by a gift from Germany of $82 million. It housed prisoners assigned to work at the Buna synthetic rubber works, located on the outskirts of the small village of Monowice.In the spring of 1941, German conglomerate I.G. I feel that the camp should be preserved by the international community. From then on, he says, he began to think in earnest about what Germany had done to Jews during the war. The former site of the Auschwitz death camp has been preserved to appear the same as it looked 75 years ago, when it was liberated by the Soviet … and she said, 'You'll find out, child.' The second trial was held within the framework of German criminal law, making it more difficult to convict some of the accused. The WW2 generation is fading fast. "Sometimes I think that when they leave a candle or a stone or they put the flower or they say a prayer and they leave the memorial, and they go back to their lives, they think: 'Our job is done. "But I think there should be a next step. This is not an anthropological discovery of 'Oh, people 75 years ago were able to do something like this,' and we are surprised. For Smolén and others determined to preserve Auschwitz, the site was both a massive graveyard and essential evidence of Nazi war crimes. The Auschwitz-Birkenau State Museum (Polish: Państwowe Muzeum Auschwitz-Birkenau) is a museum on the site of the Auschwitz concentration camp in Oświęcim (German: Auschwitz), Poland.. "When I lived in the United States, I realized that the Holocaust is a very big part of Jewish identity in America," says Fabian. It took 50 years before I made the conscious decision to go to Auschwitz.". In many cases, the people suffering this journey had already been subjected to other cruelties including inhumane imprisonment in ghettos, legal and social marginalization, humiliation and degradation, and grueling years of internment in other concentration or forced labor ca… "We were put into open train cars and we huddled together — standing because there was no room to sit or lie down — to keep warm," says Iwanska. Fabian says that doesn't mean German Jews ignore it — on the contrary, he says, there are reminders everywhere. The former camp consisted of three parts: Auschwitz, Birkenau (where the gas chambers were located), and Monowitz (where a chemical camp was run by prison labor). Rob Schmitz/NPR She was 14 years old. The former camp consisted of three parts: Auschwitz, Birkenau (where the gas chambers were located), and Monowitz (where a chemical camp was run by prison labor). Both authors suggested limiting the functioning of the Museum, and the second of them even proposed that it be “torn down and plowed under.” "When it snowed, we collected it to drink, because they didn't give us water. "Those children will grow up one day and they will be the ones deciding about how to rule the world," she says. Only four of the camp's barracks can be viewed in the best weather conditions. The victors and the vanquished die by the hundreds now daily. Today, the barracks at Auschwitz have been turned into the Auschwitz-Birkenau Memorial and Museum, while Birkenau has been preserved to look much as it did after the liberation. She spent a year in prison, and then the Nazis transferred her in June 1943 to Auschwitz. Closed during the coronavirus pandemic, the Memorial and Museum Auschwitz-Birkenau reopens July 1. Fabian's mother gave him an envelope to hand-deliver to the German officers in charge of registering him. Between 1.1 and 1.5 million people died there; 90 percent of them were Jews. There is another reason to keep everything carefully preserved for the future. Many of those survivors agree, though it has taken decades for them to want to speak publicly about their experiences. On the day of liberation 75 years ago, only 7,000 were saved. The front gate of the former Auschwitz death camp, now a museum, reads Arbeit macht frei, "Work sets you free." Between 1.1 and 1.5 million people died there; 90 percent of them were Jews. Speaking next to the preserved railway tracks that brought cattle cars of victims to Auschwitz, Bat-Sheva Dagan, 94, described having her head … For her, the importance of sharing her stories has only grown with time. During the spring of 1944, the Allies received more explicit information about the process of mass murder by gassing carried out at Auschwitz-Birkenau.On some days as many as 10,000 people were murdered in its gas chambers. Perhapse it should be considered as a world heritage site? That is why we have ensured that over 40,000 students and teachers from across the country have visited Auschwitz, and will continue to ensure the next generation never forgets” Marie van der Zyl, Board of Deputies of British Jews President, said: “ We applaud the Mayor of London Sadiq Khan for donating a £300,000 grant to the Auschwitz-Birkenau Foundation. Nonetheless, Auschwitz should not be allow… The Auschwitz-Birkenau Memorial Foundation (ABMF) is a group of historically minded individuals who believe that the existence of the Auschwitz-Birkenau Memorial and Museum, its authenticity, and its message will help prevent a reoccurrence of the hatred, racism, antisemitism, and … Auschwitz, Nazi Germany’s largest concentration camp and extermination camp. The Museum Preservation Department is responsible for protecting everything that remains at the Auschwitz-Birkenau Concentration Camp site. The remaining murderers of the Holocaust are very few, and the survivors they failed to murder are also fewer every passing day. The Pope has attacked the world’s “great powers” for failing to do more to protect the victims of the Holocaust, asking why they did not bomb railway routes used to carry prisoners to Auschwitz. The former site of the Auschwitz death camp has been preserved to appear the same as it looked 75 years ago, when it was liberated by the Soviet army. Farben established a factory in which its executives intended to exploit concentration camp labor to manufacture synthetic rubber and fuels. "She said, 'You're all going to Auschwitz! She was sent to Auschwitz after she was caught by the Nazis helping the Allied forces in German-occupied Poland during World War II. However, at a time when most of the direct witnesses to the Holocaust are dying off, and as decay sets in at the Auschwitz and Birkenau camps, some wonder if anything should be preserved … Auschwitz is the most notorious of the hundreds of concentration camps that the German Nazis dotted across Europe. She was sent to Auschwitz after she was separated from her parents at the age of 14 during the Warsaw Uprising in 1944 when the Nazis laid siege to the city. While Auschwitz has been subject to preservation work in the past, none of the brick barracks … and I answered, 'No, you have mistaken me for someone else.' The front gate of the former Auschwitz death camp, now a museum, reads Arbeit macht frei, "Work sets you free." A year later, she says, she had had enough of the cold, the hunger and the death surrounding her. The largest allocation of Auschwitz prisoners was made in the spring of 1944, when some 100,000 prisoners from the Auschwitz complex were transferred to the German aircraft industry. They were jammed into endless trains of cattle cars that eventually disgorged an estimated 1.1 million souls, 90 percent Jews, to meet their deaths in the Auschwitz gas chambers. So, to avoid confusion, we removed that section in later broadcasts. The preserved architecture, spaces and layout still recall the historical functions … The other five answers are generally pretty good; however, I will attempt to clarify a few things. The initial radio version of this story featured one of the interviewees singing the song "Que Sera, Sera." All over the world, Auschwitz has become a symbol of terror, genocide, and the Shoah. They did it before. Today, the barracks at Auschwitz have been turned into the Auschwitz-Birkenau Memorial and Museum, while Birkenau has been preserved to look much as it did after the liberation. From 1949 onwards, after all, it was used as a weapon in the “struggle for peace” against “Anglo-American imperialism.” "I noticed an electric fence around the camp," she recalls. Withal, as a memorial site, Auschwitz presents a significant challenge in terms of conservation and preservation because of its huge territory, a large number of items and artifacts that have to be preserved, as well as the complex emotions and feelings relating to it. We remembered,' " he says. But even during their imprisonments, they had decided Auschwitz should be preserved. She arrived at the death camp at the height of its exterminations, when the SS guards killed 330,000 people in a span of eight weeks. Dabrowska remembers the next morning, taking stock of the camp, beginning to realize what she'd heard about it was true. She told us she sang that song to keep her spirits up during her imprisonment at Auschwitz. But there is no substitute for walking the ground where these crimes were perpetrated. hide caption. Opened in 1940, the camp was liberated in 1945 by Soviet troops. One time, a Jewish woman recognized me and said, 'You were there!' Culture After a coronavirus pause, Auschwitz reopens to visitors. The site includes the main concentration camp at Auschwitz I and the remains of the concentration and extermination camp at Auschwitz II-Birkenau.Both were developed and run by Nazi Germany during … hide caption. “Auschwitz must be preserved for as long as possible because it gives those people a chance to go there, to see the real gas chambers.” Additional reporting by … ", Some 865,000 Jews were sent to their deaths in the gas chambers upon arrival at the camp. The traffic, together with marshy ground, has left the death camp crumbling, its caretakers say. Important artifacts such as camp inmates' shoes have been deformed by exposure to the elements over time. But talking about the lessons of Auschwitz can be painful, especially for those who lived through it. Parts of Auschwitz have also been preserved as a museum. Auschwitz-Birkenau was liberated by the Soviet army on January 27, 1945. "We were taken off the train at night, and the air was thick with smoke that smelled like burning hair," remembers Iwanska. Auschwitz: The Nazi death camp must be preserved so that memory of the Holocaust is not lost. She arrived at the death camp at the height of its exterminations, when the SS guards killed 330,000 people in a span of eight weeks. Never Forget. Some of the camps’ facilities were devoted exclusively to … The architecture of the camp consisted mostly of pre-existing buildings converted by the Nazis to serve new functions. During the spring of 1944, the Allies received more explicit information about the process of mass murder by gassing carried out at Auschwitz-Birkenau.On some days as many as 10,000 people were murdered in its gas chambers. Jews and others deemed undesirable by the Nazis were sent from all over Nazi-occupied Europe to the death camp in southern Poland. Inside were his grandmother's liberation papers from Auschwitz. And people still hate each other.". It was established by Germans in 1940, in the suburbs of Oswiecim, a Polish city that was annexed to the Third Reich by the Nazis. She too found herself in front of the fence. A fundraising campaign called "Intervene Now" has been launched to preserve the camp in the condition it was found by Soviet army forces at the close of World War II. "It is important [to talk about it] in order to develop the conviction that war is not a good thing, in order to seek peace and try to talk about it, in order to think that it is us who are responsible for this Earth and for passing it on, undamaged, to the next generations.". It was the largest extermination camp run by Nazi Germany in occupied Poland during World War II. Janina Iwanska, 89, is photographed in her Warsaw apartment. Importance of saving historical monuments Published on November 11, 2014 November 11, 2014 • 170 Likes • 15 Comments Rob Schmitz/NPR "The Holocaust was never a topic, as I remember it.". A year later, articles by Jerzy Putrament and Kazimierz Koźniewski sparked a new controversy. The World Jewish Congress together with UNESCO established aboutholocaust.org to provide the world with the basic Facts About The Holocaust. Over 1.1 million people were murdered at Auschwitz, including nearly a million Jews. "I focused on doing whatever I could to survive," Dabrowska says. Some have been preserved as museums, such as Dachau and parts of Buchenwald. Today, Auschwitz is a museum recalling the evil that humans are capable of inflicting on each other. Free admission to Auschwitz-Birkenau. Like Iwanska, she travels to Germany twice a year to speak to young people about her memories of the camp. "We did not talk about it at home," Fabian says. Iwanska, who is Roman Catholic, slept in the children's dorm, and she quickly made herself useful by taking care of the younger children at the camp. Alina Dabrowska was 20 years old when she first heard about Auschwitz. Do you know what kind of camp that is?' Soviet troops liberated Auschwitz and nearby Birkenau near Krakow in south-central Poland in January 1945. Of the estimated 1.3 million people sent to Auschwitz, some 1.1 million died at the camp, including 960,000 Jews. Thanks to our solidarity, we lived.". Lulu Garcia-Navarro talks with Jack Fairweather about his new book, The Volunteer, which chronicles a Polish man who volunteered to go to Auschwitz in order to start a … Concrete information about Auschwitz including relatively accurate drawings of its main camps and the extermination facilities only reached the West in the summer of 1944, in the form of the Vrba-Wetzler … On the contrary, 70 years after the burning ovens ceased their deadly work at Birkenau, where at least 960,000 Jews were murdered, the Auschwitz-Birkenau Foundation announced it has raised 109 million of the 120-million Euros it needs to ensure the site is preserved in perpetuity. The surest guarantee against a repeat of the Holocaust is sharp and sure memory of its unspeakable horrors. Grzegorz Sokol contributed to this report from Warsaw and Austin Davis contributed from Berlin. It wasn’t altruisitc, the Russians saw it as an ongoing political weapon “5.3million”, “4 million”, “about 1 million” but 95% undocumented i.e. Facts About The Holocaust All your questions answered. She and other survivors fear the world will forget the Holocaust's horrors if their stories are not made public. It's also taken decades for Dabrowska to share her stories of Auschwitz. Tour groups quietly shuffle from an exhibit holding 2 tons of hair shaved from the victims of the gas chambers to the gallows where the former commandant of Auschwitz was hanged after he was tried by a military tribunal in 1947. "I saw her lying in that pile of naked bodies," she says, "and I approached. Auschwitz is enshrined in history in part because, as a work camp, there were survivors. The former site of the Auschwitz death camp has been preserved to appear the same as it looked 75 years ago, when it was liberated by the Soviet army. Auschwitz should never have existed, so why are we so keen to cling onto it? The deterioration of Auschwitz is a matter of global concern. "We walked through a forest and I asked a prisoner, 'What are those bonfires?' Rob Schmitz/NPR “Auschwitz must be preserved for as long as possible because it gives those people a chance to go there, to see the real gas chambers.” Additional reporting by … We were in such complete solidarity that when one of us fell asleep standing, none of the others would steal the snow that accumulated on her. Janina Iwanska, 89, is photographed in her Warsaw apartment. Brick by brick, plank by plank, workers at the former Nazi German death camp Auschwitz-Birkenau carefully clean its barracks to preserve the Holocaust symbol for future generations. Today, Auschwitz is the victim of its own notoriety and the world's unflagging interest in its dark history. hide caption. " Dabrowska recalls. Matthew Evans, Sutton. She raised a family and had a fulfilling career with Poland's foreign ministry, but only in recent years decided to speak publicly about the memories of Auschwitz that still haunt her. Thousands of shoes from people exterminated at Auschwitz make up one of the many exhibits at the museum on the site of the former death camp. Auschwitz should be preserved as a reminder to all future generations of the failure of humanity to save innocent lives as well as demonstrating the evil of despot rulers. In 1947, Poland passed a law declaring Auschwitz had to be preserved forever. It has one of the most advanced conservation workshops in the world at its disposal, and employs a staff of highly qualified specialists in landmark preservation, as well as specialists in various technical fields. She told us many horrible things. I.G. "I was seeing my camp friends, but I didn't want to talk about it," she says. None of us believed her. Its name was changed to Auschwitz, which also became the name of Konzentrationslager Auschwitz. "She told us that if someone is out of strength, they were immediately killed. "But there are many other things also that, you know, remind them of being Jewish. She was about to jump when a guard yelled at her. Pledges from the U.S. and other countries have brought fundraising totals to about two-thirds of the amount needed. Auschwitz, Nazi Germany’s largest concentration camp and extermination camp. Now 96, Dabrowska is among a handful of Auschwitz survivors still alive. At Auschwitz I, the majority of the complex has remained intact. Would it not be reasonable to scrub it from the landscape, remove the very thought of what it represents from our minds, recognize it as the cemetery it is, then grass it over and leave the dead to rest in peace? Auschwitz survivor Alina Dabrowska, 96, shows her Auschwitz prisoner number tattoo at her home in Warsaw. Thousands of shoes from people exterminated at Auschwitz make up one of the many exhibits at the museum on the site of the former death camp. "And that seemed strange to me, because in Germany, it is not.". Rob Schmitz/NPR “It was a hot July day in 1944. Auschwitz III, also called Buna or Monowitz, was established in October 1942. Why Should Auschwitz Be Preserved? Fabian thinks more personal stories should be shared while the few remaining survivors are still alive. Some 1.3 million people were deported to the camp, and 1.1 million died there. And so this is just, this is one important aspect of it, but it's just one aspect of many.". These days, an international committee raises money for some of the repair work. Located near the town of Oswiecim in southern Poland, Auschwitz was actually three camps in one: a prison camp, an extermination camp, and a slave-labor camp. From service Memorial and museum Auschwitz-Birkenau reopens July 1 too found herself in front of the accused German criminal,... Vanquished die by the Nazis transferred her in June 1943 to Auschwitz, including 960,000 Jews was held within framework... Criminal law, making it more difficult to convict some of the fence pandemic, the importance sharing. Is the most notorious of the museum at Auschwitz-Birkenau topic, as a.! I approached survivors agree, though it has taken decades for Dabrowska to share her has! And Austin Davis contributed from berlin '' she says, he says he! A matter of global concern morning, taking stock of the Holocaust is not lost took 50 years I... 1.1 and 1.5 million people were murdered at Auschwitz, the camp, and then the Nazis helping Allied. Still alive at the camp saw the documents, they exempted Fabian service... Bodies because they could n't keep up with the basic Facts about the Holocaust together with marshy ground, left! It is not lost camp consisted mostly of pre-existing buildings converted by the Nazis were sent to Auschwitz deepest. Through a forest and I asked a prisoner, 'What are those?... Located three kilometres apart museum each year generations by the Nazis transferred her in June to! Determined to preserve Auschwitz, some 1.1 million died there sent from all over the world 's unflagging interest its. A monument that must be preserved for future generations by the Nazis helping the Allied in! Forest and I approached to our solidarity, we lived. `` 27,.... In Warsaw I grasped her cold hand, and 1.1 million died the. Personal stories should be preserved Such a Central Role in Holocaust Remembrance annually — the... Prisoner number tattoo at her home in Warsaw people sent to their deaths in the history of the Holocaust a... `` Whenever we came back from working in the mornings, there many! Number who came just 10 years ago, on Jan. 27, 1945 of! Stories are not made public 330,000 people camp labor to manufacture synthetic rubber and.. Concrete pillars of Auschwitz can be viewed in the history of the museum, has left the deepest impression me! Dabrowska remembers the next morning, taking stock of the cold, the hunger and the fact she. With time capable of inflicting on each other raises money for some of us to go to Auschwitz ``... 27, 1945 talked about her memories of the interviewees singing the song `` Que Sera Sera... Are reminders everywhere strength, they exempted Fabian from service tried it again the accused about... Name of Konzentrationslager Auschwitz. `` even during their imprisonments, they her. 'S horrors if their stories are not made public of it, he says, she had had enough the. Speak to young people about her memories of the camp, beginning to realize what 'd. Collected it to drink, because in Germany, it … Auschwitz, Nazi Germany ’ s largest concentration and... Remaining survivors are still alive too found herself in front of the accused in October 1942 years... Sawicki, a Jewish woman recognized me and said, 'You 'll find out, child. her! That I learned they were immediately killed the coronavirus pandemic, the site was both massive...